Sign up to receive expert analysis straight to your inbox with the View from Westminster email.
Receive our complimentary email newsletter, “View from Westminster”.
Keir Starmer has emphasized that he promptly took action following criticism of Labour’s sluggishness in retracting their support for a candidate who made the accusation that Israel was responsible for the Hamas attack that resulted in 1,200 fatalities.
The Labour leader made his first public statements since the controversy began on Sunday. He also refuted claims that he would have removed the prospective MP earlier if he held more left-wing views within his party.
He promised to look into accusations against any other Labour council members who were present during Azhar Ali’s highly criticized comments.
The Labour party initially supported Mr. Ali, who claimed that Israel deliberately allowed the October 7 massacre in order to attack Gaza. This statement was based on an online conspiracy theory.
However, on Monday evening, the party abruptly removed him from his position when it was revealed that he had made accusations against “individuals in the media with ties to the Jewish community” for contributing to the backlash against a member of parliament advocating for Palestine.
The Conservative party stated that the uproar demonstrated that the accusations of Labour’s transformation under Sir Keir were baseless.
A gathering of Conservative Members of Parliament, which includes former Secretary of Defence Ben Wallace, has sent a letter to the Labour party inquiring about the attendance of any Labour MPs or councillors at the meeting and whether they expressed disagreement with the statements made.
While campaigning in Wellingborough, Sir Keir addressed the delay and explained that new information had emerged over the weekend regarding the candidate. The candidate issued a sincere apology, but after additional information came to light yesterday, Sir Keir felt it was necessary to take swift and decisive action.
Withdrawing support for a Labour candidate during a by-election is a significant action. It is a difficult and essential decision, and I stand by my statement that the Labour Party has transformed under my leadership. I want to make it clear that my support for Mr Ali was not based on factionalism, as an individual’s position within the Labour Party holds no weight for me.
Previously, Mr. Forde had characterized the response of the Labour party in the 48 hours following Mr. Ali’s initial statements as “disorganized.”
He denounced the comments as “blatantly anti-Semitic” and “provocative”, and stated that Labour should have retracted its endorsement over the weekend: “That, in my opinion, would have been the logical course of action.”
The speaker expressed doubt about the process of choosing such individuals and mentioned that Labor MPs with left-leaning views feel that there has been unequal treatment regarding accusations of antisemitism.
In 2022, Mr. Forde conducted an investigation, requested by Keir Starmer, which revealed that both the left and right factions of the party had utilized anti-Semitism as a means of gaining power during former leader Jeremy Corbyn’s tenure.
Lord Mann, the current government official responsible for addressing antisemitism, and a former member of the Labour Party, stated that it was not unexpected for Labour to retract its backing.
He urged political leaders from various parties to come together and address the issue, cautioning against the spread of anti-Semitic sentiments throughout the nation.
Labour Member of Parliament, Steve McCabe, also characterized the situation as “embarrassing” for his party. However, he stood by the choice to support him at first, stating that they wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt and believe that his apology was sincere.
Initially, Mr. Ali apologized for his comments during a Lancashire Labour Party meeting where he stated that Israel used the October 7 Hamas attack as a justification for invading Gaza.
A representative for the party announced on Monday evening that Labour has revoked their support due to “recently obtained information” regarding the potential MP, who is believed to have been suspended while an investigation takes place.
The Labour party has temporarily removed MP Kate Osamor from her position after she made comments implying that the Gaza war should be recognized as genocide on Holocaust Memorial Day. She later apologized for her remarks.
Diane Abbott, a long-serving MP, had her party membership revoked for her statement in a letter to the Observer last year, where she insinuated that individuals of Jewish, Irish, and Traveller descent do not experience racism throughout their entire lives.
She expressed regret and proposed that there were “mistakes” made during the drafting of the letter.
Mr. Forde pointed out two instances where disciplinary measures seemed to take longer for certain members of the party, while others were handled quickly.
Sir Keir has proudly claimed to have revitalized his party following disputes surrounding accusations of anti-Semitism during Jeremy Corbyn’s tenure as leader.
Conservative politician Lee Rowley criticized Labour for avoiding the controversy, as no opposition minister made an appearance on Tuesday morning’s media.
He asked Sky News about the whereabouts of Labour today.
On Monday, Pat McFadden, the national campaign coordinator for Labour, stated that the party took action due to the emergence of new information and additional comments. This prompted a reevaluation of the situation.
According to a representative, Keir Starmer has transformed the Labour party into something unrecognizable from its state in 2019. While we recognize the unique circumstances, it is crucial that any Labour candidate fully reflects the party’s goals and principles. As nominations have closed, Azhar Ali cannot be substituted as the candidate.
The recent change in position by Labour has caused confusion regarding the potential outcome of the Rochdale election at the end of this month.
Additionally, remaining in the running are former member of Parliament for Labour, Simon Danczuk, who is now a candidate for the Reform Party, and former Labour MP George Galloway, representing the Workers Party of Britain and actively opposing Labour’s position on Gaza.
Recent surveys indicate that the Labour party may experience a decrease in voter support due to dissatisfaction with their apparent endorsement of Israel.
If chosen, Mr Ali will serve as an unaffiliated member of Parliament and will not be bound by party rules.
A representative from the Campaign Against Antisemitism expressed that Sir Keir’s actions have tarnished an otherwise commendable record and raised doubts about his commitment to eradicating antisemitism from the Labour party. It is up to individuals to decide if the recently revealed statements by Azhar Ali are more concerning than the previously reported ones.