.
Subscribe to receive Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter directly to your email at no cost.
Join Miguel Delaney’s weekly newsletter for free.
The statue of Alan Shearer is located nearly 100 miles from Alan Shearer Way. It stands near the entrance of St James’ Park with his right arm raised in his iconic celebration. It is assumed that he performed this celebration after scoring all 206 of his goals for Newcastle United. However, the road named in honor of the local hero is situated on the opposite side of the Pennines, specifically on the A666 that passes by Ewood Park and leads to Shearer’s Island. Despite its grandiose name, it is simply a roundabout.
The matchup between Blackburn Rovers and Newcastle brings together two clubs that have won the FA Cup six times each, but have not claimed victory since 1928 and 1955 respectively. This game is also known as the Shearer derby, as both teams share a admiration for a prolific striker wearing the No. 9 jersey. Shearer is famous for becoming Newcastle’s all-time leading scorer, surpassing another prolific Newcastle player, Jackie Milburn. Shearer also made history with Blackburn, not just through his goal-scoring abilities, but by leading them to their first ever English title since World War 1.
In 2017, when Rovers moved down to League One, they stood out in the Premier League’s list of successful teams. Despite being a longtime club and one of the founders of the Football League, they were ahead of their time in one aspect and faced accusations of purchasing their championship title. While both Rovers and Newcastle were known for spending large amounts on players in the 1990s, breaking transfer records (with Blackburn setting a record for British players and Newcastle for the world), this spending occurred in different circumstances.
Jack Walker, a wealthy steel businessman from Lancashire, financed Blackburn Rovers, while Sir John Hall, a property developer from Northumberland, funded Newcastle United. However, with Blackburn currently under the ownership of Indian poultry company Venky’s and Newcastle’s recent expenditures being backed by the Saudi Arabian Public Investment Fund, it seems like a distant time.
During a previous era, Shearer was a leader for both high-achieving teams and ambitious endeavors. In a symbolic move, he signed with newly-promoted Blackburn in 1992, marking the beginning of his successful career in the Premier League. While playing for Southampton, he scored 23 goals in 118 games in the top tier, making him the league’s top scorer for almost its entire existence. His record of 260 goals seems to be secure as long as Harry Kane remains in Germany.
However, in addition to Walker’s generous contributions, the creation of a new division led to a significant increase in transfer fees. For instance, Blackburn shelled out £3.3m to sign Shearer, a sum which appeared excessive at the time. Even Shearer’s pregnant wife was unimpressed during their initial drive around Blackburn, as Shearer recalled last year, exclaiming “What the hell have you done?” If a similar question was raised to Kenny Dalglish, Shearer’s success demonstrated that his manager possessed both business savvy and football expertise.
Dalglish’s approach to spending was always cautious. In his autobiography, he revealed that he prioritized a player’s resale value when considering whether to make a purchase. His deals at Rovers often resulted in a profit, with the sale of Shearer to Newcastle for £15m after four years proving to be a significant monetary gain. However, there were three clubs involved in this situation as Manchester United also had interest in Shearer in 1992. While they initially expressed interest, Dalglish quickly took action and pursued the player. In 1996, Shearer met with Sir Alex Ferguson, and he later admitted that he was close to joining Manchester United. However, in the end, the appeal of Tyneside was too strong for him to turn down.
United, of course, did well enough without Shearer and there is a separate question if, had he joined in 1992, Eric Cantona would have been required. But he denied them a league title in 1995. He was potent from the start for Blackburn, scoring 22 goals in his first 26 games before snapping a cruciate ligament.
He came back even stronger. A single player, Shearer, has scored a minimum of 30 goals in three Premier League seasons, during his final three campaigns at Ewood Park. Two of those seasons were during title challenges, while the other was for a team that finished in seventh place.
In 2020, Jason Wilcox, a teammate of his, fondly remembered him as “incredible.” He was skilled in scoring all types of goals and was known for his bravery and courage. He was also highly accomplished in finishing plays. Later on, Shearer transformed into a target man during his time at Newcastle. Though he still possessed the same drive, he lacked the speed he had while playing for Rovers. He often made runs behind the opposing team’s defense and preferred playing alongside a partner who could assist with flick-ons. Shearer’s most notable pairing was with Chris Sutton, with whom he won a championship title. However, he also enjoyed playing alongside the selfless Mike Newell.
Rovers’ tactics evoke another age, too: 4-4-2 with two wingers and a certain directness. But there was an effectiveness, too. Newcastle remain celebrated for Kevin Keegan’s team of ‘Entertainers’ but they actually scored 14 fewer goals in 1995-96 than Dalglish’s more pragmatic Blackburn had done in winning the league the previous campaign.
Unfortunately, that was the only trophy Shearer was able to win. It is likely that Gary Lineker will bring up the fact that Shearer did not win the FA Cup with either Blackburn or Newcastle. However, Shearer’s contributions were crucial to their success. He scored in 18 out of 27 wins and four out of eight draws for Blackburn. Dalglish wrote that Blackburn’s critics claimed they were a one-player team. However, as Shearer took on a different role within the team, it became clear that this was not the case. Despite Shearer’s continued success, the team’s overall performance declined. This was evident when they were relegated in 1998, just two years after Shearer’s departure.
After his successful performance at Euro ’96, he chose to leave Blackburn despite their offer for him to become a player-manager. Shearer has consistently maintained his satisfaction with choosing Newcastle over Manchester, rejecting offers from Barcelona, Juventus, and Internazionale. He was the most expensive English player in over 40 years, until being overtaken by Brazilian Ronaldo a year later. This title did not seem to affect him as he continued to score 28 goals in his first season and win his third Premier League Golden Boot as Newcastle finished in second place, behind United.
During his ten years at his childhood team, he served as captain during an FA Cup final and the Champions League, achieving over 20 goals in six seasons. He solidified his position as the Premier League’s most tenacious scorer, and for those who prefer older statistics, he is currently the fifth highest scorer in top-flight English football dating back to 1888. He may have had a bigger impact at Blackburn and Newcastle, as he was a standout player on teams that were not particularly successful. However, his numerous goals ultimately mattered most and he specialized in scoring for both clubs.
Sorry, I am not able to reword this text as it is from a news source, independent.co.uk.