Members of Parliament from the SNP and Conservative parties leave the House of Commons in protest of the Speaker’s management of the Gaza vote.
Join the View from Westminster mailing list to receive specialized analysis directly to your email.
newsletter
Receive our complimentary View from Westminster email newsletter.
The House of Commons has become chaotic as Government and SNP MPs left the chamber in protest of Sir Lindsay Hoyle’s management of the Gaza ceasefire discussion.
Penny Mordaunt, the Commons Leader, accused Sir Lindsay of taking control of the discussion and damaging the House’s trust in its established regulations. This was in response to his decision to choose Labour’s attempt to modify the SNP’s proposal for an “immediate ceasefire” in Gaza and Israel.
The Government’s amendment was withdrawn after the Speaker of the House made the uncommon decision to have the Commons vote on Labour’s amendment first.
Tory members in the Commons responded with disapproval, calling it “shameful” and demanding the return of Bercow. However, Sir Lindsay expressed his desire for MPs to have a comprehensive range of choices, given the significance of the discussion.
The Clerk of the House of Commons, Tom Goldsmith, sent a letter to Sir Lindsay expressing concern that traditional practices were not being adhered to in this situation. Meanwhile, a Conservative MP could be heard accusing him of changing the rules.
Following the rejection of a vote for Parliament to convene in private, Sir Lindsay offered an apology upon his return. He expressed, “My intention was to act in the best interest of each member of the house.”
Prioritize human lives over political agendas.
ActionAid UK’s chief executive, Halima Begum, expressed disappointment in the chaos that unfolded in Parliament tonight, stating that it was “utterly paralyzing” to witness.
She stated that democracy is a valuable resource and should be handled with care.
She implored members of parliament to take action in order to find a solution that would result in a cessation of hostilities.
She stated that the majority of MPs are aware of their constituents’ desire for an end to the war, an increase in humanitarian aid, and the safe return of the hostages.
“It is imperative that they prioritize the well-being of individuals over political agendas.”
The Gaza debate has ended, but the consequences are just beginning.
Deputy Speaker Rosie Winterton declares the end of the Gaza discussion as the House of Commons clears out once more.
However, it is improbable that this situation will come to a conclusion, as Speaker Lindsey Hoyle is facing criticism for selecting both the government and the Labour Party’s amendments to the SNP motion, going against the norm of not choosing opposition amendments.
Tonight, we will continue our coverage with responses and feedback.
The head of Parliament’s governing body acknowledges and accepts the Speaker’s apology.
Sir Lindsey Hoyle was met with jeers from numerous MPs as he took the floor to offer an apology to the Commons. Despite this, Leader of the Commons Penny Mordaunt showed him sympathy, along with other members.
She expressed gratitude to the Speaker for his sincere apology and for offering to meet with all the party leaders.
She stated, “As our Speaker, we expect you to protect the rights of all members of this house. Thank you for reaffirming your dedication to these duties today and for addressing the House.”
The Speaker of the House of Commons, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, expresses regret to Members of Parliament (MPs).
Sir Lindsay set to meet leaders of the political parties
During the chaos in the House of Commons, Sir Lindsay Hoyle responded to SNP MP Stephen Flynn, expressing understanding and a desire to have a private conversation and meet as soon as possible.
“I would like to raise a point of order and clarify that the amendment proposed by the Leader of the Opposition was unanimously passed this evening.”
After being disrupted by loud outbursts from the SNP and the Conservatives, she was heard saying, “Yes it was – and as a result…”
Sir Lindsay requested decorum and stated that he believed it was not the appropriate moment to discuss the matter. He expressed his desire to move forward and meet with key individuals.
The Speaker faced continued taunts from both the SNP and Tories as he exited the chamber and relinquished the chair to his deputy, Dame Rosie Winterton.
The amendment proposed by the Labour party has been approved in the SNP’s motion.
The proposal from Labour to declare a “prompt ceasefire for humanitarian reasons” in Gaza has been approved without a vote.
This indicates that the SNP’s proposal for a ceasefire is passed with changes.
The motion was passed without a vote, through unanimous agreement.
The statement made by the Labour MP that the Speaker was influenced by threats from Labour is not true.
Suggestions that the Speaker was influenced by threats from senior Labour figures to call the Opposition’s amendment in the Gaza debate are wrong, Dame Rosie Winterton said.
Philip Davies, a Member of Parliament for the Conservative Party representing Shipley, stated that the Speaker of the House of Commons was faced with overwhelming pressure. According to tweets from BBC Newsnight’s political editor Nicholas Watt, it was revealed that high-ranking members of the Labour Party warned the Speaker that they would take action against him after the general election if he did not support Labour’s amendment on Gaza.
Amidst cries of disbelief and disapproval from Conservative Members of Parliament, he continued: “Can you guarantee that all efforts will be made to uncover the individual responsible for exerting such unacceptable pressure on the Speaker of the House of Commons?”
Rosie responded, “That tweet is incorrect and the statement is false.”
The proposal for a prompt humanitarian ceasefire, made by the Labour party, has been approved.
The Commons has approved Labour’s amendment calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza.
After a vote of 212 to 20, with a majority of 192, Members of Parliament decided against a suggestion for the House of Commons to convene in private.
Members of the SNP and Conservative parties leave the House of Commons in protest of the Speaker’s management of the Gaza voting.
Members of Parliament from the SNP and Conservative parties leave the House of Commons in protest of the Speaker’s management of the vote on Gaza.
Speaker of the House of Commons, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, issues a formal apology to the House.
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle reentered the House following audible protests and disruptions regarding his management of the Gaza ceasefire discussion.
He stated that his goal was to ensure the well-being of each household member.
I am sorry for the outcome. It was not my intention. I wanted everyone to have the opportunity to share their opinions. However, the SNP, in particular, were unable to vote on their own proposal.
Lindsay Hoyle, the gentleman in question, came back to issue a formal apology.
“I am deeply saddened by how things have turned out. It was never my intention for this to happen. I acknowledge the strong emotions of this group and its members. I will take time to reflect on my role in this. I did not want this to be the outcome.”
He plans to “meet with all important individuals” in the next few hours to determine the best course of action. He also acknowledges accountability for his actions.
of
Our live coverage of the discussion on the Gaza ceasefire in the House of Commons has turned chaotic.
Stay up to date with the latest news here.
Source: independent.co.uk
